We reviewed dozens of sandwich toasters to find the 10 best options for you
Links to products may be affiliate links. We earn a commission, however, this is at no extra cost to you.
The best sandwich toasters are super quick to heat up, will produce a tight seal around your toasties to prevent escapees and an evenly browned finish while being easy to clean, maintain and fit in a cupboard.
In this review, we have compiled a list of the best sandwich toasters to help you find the most suitable sandwich makers for your needs and at the most affordable price. From deep filled options to wide plate or multi-use snack makers.
The Perfect Press sandwich toaster offers the ultimate place for you to press your toasted sandwiches. It isn’t the first time that Sage has created an appliance to make it high up on our lists, and there are a number of reasons why this toasted sandwich maker deserves its place.
It doesn’t have to be a selfish snack; you can make the ultimate comfort food for you and a friend with the ability to cook up two portions at once. Ideal if you’re cooking for hungry mouths i.e. teenagers or a family lunch, or alternatively if you are just out for making a quick snack for yourself the Perfect Press sandwich toaster will enable you to select the 2 slice only function.
Because it has hot plates as opposed to dedicated sandwich sections, it’s ideal for deep fill toasties, you also have the possibility of making paninis and using other forms or bread, from sourdough to larger slices of Warburton’s Toastie which others may struggle to fit in. There is also a floating hinge and deep fill plates if you like to pack everything you can find into the toastie and otherwise struggle to close the lid. Crush control applies the perfect amount of pressure without squashing the contents.
The plates are perfectly non-stick so it is simple to clean, and it can be stored vertically when you’re done.
Breville are industry leaders when it comes to sandwich toasters and this deep fill toaster accentuates that point. It’s reasonably priced for a higher-end toastie maker, yet still has everything you need to rustle up your best sandwich or late-night snack.
This deep fill toastie maker enables you to prepare two sandwiches at once, and because each slice of bread has a dedicated segment, the sandwich is cut and sealed as it toasts, keeping the filling securely inside.
The cooking surface is non-stick, plus it is also non-greasy, so you can safely oil and prepare it without this being transferred onto your sandwich. The toastie plates can be removed when it comes to washing them, and they are dishwasher too. If you get bored of toasties you can have fun with sweet and savoury waffles!
Able to cook two portions, this sandwich toaster is great if you occasionally get that toastie craving but don’t need a big, overly-complicated sandwich toaster.
The Logic L02SMS17 sandwich toaster is by far one of the cheapest on the market at under £10, yet the performance doesn’t match the price tag. It does what it needs to, evenly browning bread and melting the inside of the filling.
The plates are non-stick, and it is lightweight and quite compact so can be stored away. Plus, the cord wrap ensures it is tidy and doesn’t make a mess when you put it away.
It makes more sense to have one sandwich toaster in a cafe, which can toast traditional toasties, paninis, baguettes, ciabattas, and croissants. This is the basis on which Breville have created this sandwich press, too.
The flat non-stick plates can fit sandwiches of all shapes and sizes, and all you have to do is place them within the press and lower the lid. No complicated fitting or squeezing it all in.
You can store it upright, and the lockable lid ensures it remains in place and its easy to bring out again when you need it.
If a sandwich maker isn’t good enough for you then why not check out this 3-in-1 option? This sandwich toaster will save you valuable storage space on multiple appliances as it is a sandwich toaster, waffle maker and grill all in one.
So, if you are weighing up the cost of a health grill and sandwich toaster then the VonShef 3 in 1 sandwich toaster could fit the bill. Removable plates make the cleanup process especially if you have some escapee melted cheese.
This is our budget pick. Despite not being the best sandwich maker, waffle machine or grill money can buy, it still does the job well. There are alternative sandwich toasters that offer more power, but at 700 W it still offers enough and you’ll have some fun Saturday afternoons in the kitchen.
Waring may not be the most well-known brand but we are willing to vouch for this toastie maker.
It is deep fill, enabling you to pack a thick sandwich full of layers of melted cheese, meats and extras. It has space for two big portions and in addition, to prepare deep filled toasties, you can also enjoy an omelette, calzone and more.
It comes with three heat settings and removable non stick plates making it very easy to clean up after use. The compact design and easy-to-use dial make this toastie maker a perfect choice.
There’s an art to making good toasties and this sandwich maker is easy to use and gives perfect results time after time.
Offering two generous deep portion spaces you can pack them with layers of fillings and not struggle to lower the lid. It’s non-stick, so your sandwiches will come out healthily and also in one piece.
The whole idea of this sandwich maker is convenience, and this brand has remembered that. You can adjust the temperature with one dial and there is no need to mess around with further fancy settings.
1000W of power makes for quick and perfect results too, the bread will be crispy yet the insides melted.
Russell Hobbs are a reputable appliance company constantly raising the bar with kitchen essentials. This toastie maker can hold five portions. The surface is non-stick, so your toastie can be taken out in one piece and it’s easy to clean.
It has a power rating of 1960W, which makes it one of the most powerful on the market. This will get your sandwiches toasted in no time. You also get a hinged lid, so can toast thicker baguettes or doorstop-style bread.
This all-round Tefal sandwich toaster is robust and reliable enabling you to cook two toasties at once.
You can also use this toaster for more than just toasting your favourite sandwiches. It has 14 additional sets of plates you can collect, so you can make everything from doughnuts to bagels. making it the ideal product if you want several snack makers but only have space for one or two.
When storing, the plates can all be popped into a box so they are kept together, and the actual toaster can be stored upright to save some space.
The light on the top of the unit lets you know when it’s ready to go, and its locking latch keeps everything in place when toasting.
Here’s another Breville sandwich toaster, this time for less than £20.
The reason for this toaster making it into our top 10 is down to the quality to value ratio. It is one of the most affordable and compact sandwich makers and great for those not wanted to spend too much.
Breville has really thought about storage and the VST078 has fon-slip feet, cord storage and a locking lid and you can even store upright.
The plates are coated in a unique DuraCeramic formula, to reduce the contents sticking and it is easy to clean with a damp cloth once cooled. Because of the dedicated slots, it also benefits from a cut and seal system, for ideal toastie pockets with contained filling.
Before committing to purchasing your sandwich toaster there are a few key features you will want to check over.
This will depend on the size of your family and of course if you want to cook more than just thick slices of bread, will you be interested in the odd panini too?
At a minimum, you will want to be able to hold 2 slices, but if you want more flexibility you may want to choose a toastie maker with a flat plates as opposed to one with dedicated sandwich sections, and if it is just sandwiches that you are interested in then maybe look for a deep fill sandwich toaster.
In our opinion, the best toasted sandwich makers will have a non-stick coating on the cooking plates, and even a PFOA-Free non stick coating, making them easier to clean.
When you start shopping for sandwich toasters you will notice that some, not all come with cooking plates that can be swapped in and out. Making the humble sandwich toaster more into a multi-kitchen appliance. Some will enable you to use the toaster as a grill or even a waffle machine, which can be handy if you are short of space and also keen to have a grill.
Another benefit to multipurpose plates is that make for an easy clean sandwich toaster. They are easy to pop out for cleaning purposes. You will just need to wait until they are cool enough to handle and then either wash by hand or use pop in your microwave.
Sandwich toasters make delicious toasties fast. Therefore you will want to find a sandwich toast that heats up quickly. Look for a toastie maker that is 700 Watts or above.
Toastie makers get hot fast. They are well-made kitchen appliances and retain their heat, so the exterior should remain fine to touch without burning you when you prepare your sandwich. You will also find that good sandwich toasters have non-slip feet and also include indicator lights so you know when they are hot enough to cook on.
If you have read this far, you will know who we have ranked as the front-runners for our best sandwich toaster review. Sage The Perfect Press paves the way with its smart technology and innovation that cannot be found in counterparts.
A sandwich maker as a whole is certainly a welcomed small appliance addition in our homes and that is because they are convenient and simple to use. The ultimate comfort food is never more than a few minutes away when you own a good toastie maker, all you need is bread (preferably think slices) and a filling of your choice.
If you’ve made your decision and your sandwich maker is on its way. What will you make first?
Making toasted sandwiches is a simple process, If you need inspiration on what you can make with your toastie makers check out Olive’s best toastie recipes or, you could just raid your kitchen cupboard and experiment with your ingredients!
Cheese toasties may be what comes to mind first, but some cooked meat such as ham, a little coleslaw, cheese and a sliver of gerkin also work well! It’s not hard to see why these simple yet effective toastie makers get our vote.
You just need to find the best sandwich toaster for you, and that will be one that suits your budget and has everything that you need- the best toastie makers come in different shapes and sizes and some go further than just toasties cooked to perfection. If you and your family like waffles some sandwich toasters double up as waffle makers and/or health grill.
I had the idea for Which Kitchen Appliance? In 2016 when a friend was planning a new kitchen and asked me to help her choose her new kitchen appliances. She knew that I had trained as a chef, had a passion for cooking and an interest in interior design.
After hours and hours of trawling websites looking for a double oven, built-in microwave, hob & extractor fan the excitement that was soon waned…we were bored and frazzled. But finally, we succeeded and she got her new kitchen.
This led me to think that there must be a better way of researching kitchen appliances, if only there were somewhere that you could go and find kitchen appliance reviews and helpful hints and tips on getting the best from and look after your appliance under one roof with information that was comprehensive, easy to understand and that you could trust…and so WhichKitchenAppliance? was born. I now work full-time on WhichKitchenAppliance?